Product Image

Auditing Revenue in Certain Industries — AICPA Audit Guide

Publisher: AICPA
Availability: In Stock
See Below To Add To Cart

Description

This Audit Guide provides the latest information on auditing issues involving revenue recognition, and specifically those issues affecting the computer software and high-technology manufacturing industries. Updated with conforming changes as of March 1, 2008, it includes guidance in planning and performing audits under the risk assessment standards (SAS Nos. 104-111). This edition of the guide has also been conformed to reflect the Defining Professional Requirements standard (SAS No. 102).

The guide summarizes applicable requirements and practices, and delivers "how-to" advice for handling audit and accounting issues common to both the computer software and high-technology manufacturing industries. It describes the conceptual basis for revenue recognition, contract accounting, software revenue recognition, accounting for bill and hold sales, sales of real estate, and includes discussion of other relevant financial statement considerations. The guide covers the following new pronouncements:

  • FASB Statement No. 157, Fair Value Measurements
  • EITF Issue No. 07-01, Accounting for Collaborative Arrangements
  • PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 5, An Audit of Internal Control Over Financial Reporting That Is Integrated with An Audit of Financial Statements
For a topical listing of subject matter by chapter, click on the Table of Contents tab.

Table of Contents

  • Overview: Audit Issues in Revenue Recognition
    • Responsibility for Reliable Reporting
      • Deterrents to Improper Revenue Recognition
      • Internal Control and Assertions About Revenue
    • Summary of Selected Accounting Literature on Revenue Recognition
      • Conceptual Basis for Revenue Recognition
      • Revenue Recognition When Right of Return Exists
      • Contract Accounting
      • SOP 97-2, Software Revenue Recognition
      • SEC Codification of Staff Accounting Bulletins, Topic 13: Revenue Recognition
      • Bill and Hold Sales
      • Sales of Real Estate
      • Financial Statement Disclosures
      • Other Sources of Revenue Recognition Guidance
    • Indicators of Improper Revenue Recognition
      • Risk Factors Relating to Misstatements Arising From Fraudulent Financial Reporting
      • Other Issues to Consider
      • Potential Accounting Misstatements
    • Auditing Revenue Assertions
      • Audit Planning
      • Audit Risk
      • Planning Materiality
      • Use of Assertions in Obtaining Audit Evidence
      • Understanding the Entity, Its Environment, and Its Internal Control
      • Understanding of Internal Control Over Revenue Recognition
      • Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement
      • Designing and Performing Further Audit Procedures
      • Cutoff Tests, Vouching, and Other Substantive Tests of Details
      • Confirmations
      • Evaluating Accounting Estimates Relevant to Revenue Recognition
      • Observation of Inventory
      • Evaluating Misstatements
      • Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit
      • Transactions With Related Parties
  • Overview: Audit Issues in Revenue Recognition—continued Analytical Procedures
      • Management Representations
      • Adequacy of Disclosure
      • Evaluation of Audit Evidence
  • Auditing Revenue Transactions in the Computer Software Industry
    • Overview of the Computer Software Industry
      • Types of Revenue Transactions
      • Competitive Environment
    • Summary of Significant Accounting Guidance Relevant to Software Revenue Recognition
      • Software Revenue Recognition
      • Barter and Other Nonmonetary Transactions
      • Accounting for Price Protection Agreements
      • Accounting for Collaborative Arrangements
      • Sales Returns
    • Obtaining an Understanding of Software Revenue Transactions
      • Inherent Risk Considerations
    • Consideration of Fraud
      • Fraud Risk Factors
      • Responses to the Presence of Fraud Risk Factors
    • Obtaining an Understanding of Internal Control
      • Control Environment
      • Risk Assessment
      • Control Activities
      • Information and Communication
      • Monitoring
      • Assessing Control Risk
    • Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement
      • Identification of Significant Risks
    • Designing and Performing Further Audit Procedures
      • Overall Responses
      • Further Audit Procedures
    • Tests of Controls
    • Substantive Procedures
      • Types of Potential Misstatement
      • Read and Analyze Contracts
      • Confirm Terms of the Arrangement
      • Test for Delivery
      • Test for Collectibility
      • Test for Contingencies
  • Auditing Revenue Transactions in the Computer Software Industry—continued
    • Gather Audit Evidence to Support VSOE or Residual Value
      • Test Recognition of Deferred Revenue
      • Analyze Allowance for Sales Returns
    • Designing Analytical Procedures
    • Presentation and Disclosure
    • Written Representations From Management
  • Auditing Revenue Transactions in the High-Technology Manufacturing Industry
    • Overview of the High-Technology Manufacturing Industry
      • Competitive Environment
      • Characteristics of Revenue Transactions
    • Summary of Significant Accounting Guidance
      • Is the Product Sold Together With Services?
      • Applicability of SOP 97-2, Software Revenue Recognition
      • Accounting for Product Sales
      • Accounting for Transactions That Involve Both Products and Services
      • Accounting for Services
      • Accounting for Maintenance Agreements and Extended Warranties
      • Accounting for Bill and Hold Sales
      • Accounting for Price Protection Agreements
      • Accounting for Sales With a Guaranteed Minimum Resale Value
    • Obtaining an Understanding of Revenue Transactions in the High-Technology Manufacturing Industry
      • Inherent Risk Considerations
    • Consideration of Fraud
      • Fraud Risk Factors
      • Responses to the Presence of Fraud Risk Factors
    • Obtaining an Understanding of Internal Control
      • Control Environment
      • Risk Assessment
      • Control Activities
      • Information and Communication
      • Monitoring
      • Assessing Control Risk
  • Auditing Revenue Transactions in the High-Technology Manufacturing Industry—continued
    • Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement
      • Identification of Significant Risks
    • Designing and Performing Further Audit Procedures
      • Overall Responses
      • Further Audit Procedures
    • Test of Controls
    • Substantive Procedures
      • Types of Potential Misstatement
      • Understand Terms of Sale
      • Understand Arrangements With Distributors and VARs
      • Confirm Terms of the Sale
      • Test for Product Shipment
      • Test for Collectibility
      • Test Recognition of Deferred Revenue
      • Analyze Allowance for Sales Returns
    • Designing Analytical Procedures
    • Presentation and Disclosure
    • Written Representations From Management
  • Appendix
  • A Major Existing Differences Between AICPA Standards and PCAOB Standards
  • B Comparison of Key Provisions of the Risk Assessment Standards to Previous Standards
  • C Schedule of Changes Made to the Text From the Previous Edition

012518

Excerpts

Purpose and Applicability

Revenue recognition continues to pose significant audit risk to auditors and has contributed to perceived erosion in the integrity of the financial reporting process. In recent years, several high-profile incidents of improper revenue recognition attracted the attention of the business media and led to unflattering coverage. A substantial portion of recent litigation against accounting firms reported to the AICPA Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Practice Section Quality Control Inquiry Committee cite revenue recognition issues. In March 1999, the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) released Fraudulent Financial Reporting: 1987–1997, An Analysis ofU.S. Public Companies. The report examines incidents of fraudulent financial reporting alleged by the SEC in Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Releases issued between January 1987 and December 1997. More than half of the frauds involved overstating revenues by recording them either fictitiously or prematurely. In August 2000, the Public Oversight Board's Panel on Audit Effectiveness, established in October 1998 in response to a request by the SEC, published its final report. The report included recommendations that the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the AICPA's Auditing Standards Board (ASB) provide additional guidance on revenue. On May 1, 2002 the Public Oversight Board terminated its operations and the SEC Practice Section of the AICPA ceased existence on December 31, 2003, transferring is operations and oversight responsibility to The Center for Public Company Audit Firms, which commenced operations on January 1, 2004. Its membership is voluntary. On January 30, 2007, the center changed its name to "The Center for Audit Quality." More information can be found at www.thecaq.org.

The implications are wide reaching. Investor confidence has driven the unparalleled success of the U.S. capital markets, and a key component in creating that confidence is the confirming role of audited financial statements. In this guide, the AICPA's intent is to help auditors fulfill their professional responsibilities with regard to auditing assertions about revenue. This guide—
  • Discusses the responsibilities of management, boards of directors, and audit committees for reliable financial reporting.
  • Summarizes key accounting guidance regarding whether and when revenue should be recognized in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).
  • Identifies circumstances and transactions that may signal improper revenue recognition.
  • Summarizes key aspects of the auditor's responsibility to plan and perform an audit under generally accepted auditing standards (GAAS).
  • Describes procedures that the auditor may find effective in limiting audit risk arising from improper revenue recognition.
  • Provides guidance on auditing revenue transactions in selected industries not covered by existing AICPA Audit and Accounting Guides.
  • The primary focus of this publication is revenue recognition for sales of goods and services (other than lending activities) by for-profit entities in the ordinary course of business. Revenue recognition for governmental and not-for-profit entities is beyond the scope of this publication. The FASB has an active comprehensive revenue recognition project on its agenda. The objective of this project is to develop a comprehensive statement on revenue recognition that is conceptually based and framed in terms of principles. This project intends to (a) convergeU.S. and international standards on revenue recognition, (b) eliminate inconsistencies in the existing conceptual guidance on revenues, (c) provide conceptual guidance that would be useful in addressing revenue recognition issues that may arise in the future, (d) eliminate the inconsistencies in the existing authoritative literature and accepted practices, (e) fill the voids that have emerged in revenue recognition guidance in recent years, and (f) establish a single, comprehensive standard on revenue recognition. Although the FASB plans for this statement to apply to business entities generally, it might later decide to exclude certain transactions or industries requiring additional study. The FASB's goal is to issue a due process document in the second quarter of 2008 covering two models, including concepts-level and standards-level revenue recognition guidance. Readers should be alert to the progress of this project because it may affect the accounting described in this guide.

    012518

Subscription Info

Paperback 2008
Product# 012518
Availability:In Stock
*Discounted price reflected in Shopping Cart
Regular:$73.75
AICPA Member:$59.00
Your Price:$73.75
To receive your AICPA member discount, Sign In now, or Register using your AICPA membership number.
Choose the Standing Order Option and get these discounts on your initial purchase:

Publications--10% discount
CPE Self-Study--20% discount

Each new future annual edition will then be automatically shipped to you at a 10% discount.